Skip to main content

Starmer’s holiday from reality is over

 

Good morning.

Sir Keir Starmer has returned from Chequers to find that none of his old problems have gone away. He is still facing widespread ridicule for his policies on migration and his knowledge of Lord Mandelson’s friendship with Jeffrey Epstein. All the Prime Minister can offer is foreign policy posturing, while Britain races towards national bankruptcy.

 

Allister Heath, Sunday Telegraph Editor

Starmer’s holiday from reality is over

Cartoon showing Sir Keir Starmer arriving at No 10 Downing Street with a suitcase labelled 'Windsor'
 

Sir Keir Starmer’s holiday from reality didn’t last long. After a short break giving an awe-struck Donald Trump a tour of old Britain, with the help of the Royal family, the PM has been plunged back into his perma-crisis.

He is facing widespread ridicule for his one-in, one-out illegal migration policy, which has so far succeeded in deporting just a handful of migrants, even though hundreds more arrived on English shores on Friday. The tiny probability of being deported under Starmer’s scheme is making no noticeable difference to the rational calculus of migrants and people smugglers.

It’s a farce, and it merely exposes the impotency of a Labour Government wedded to the status quo on human rights, the ECHR, the Human Rights Act and Britain’s membership to various United Nations conventions.

No wonder Starmer has just lost a council by-election in Cardiff, of all places, to Reform and that he has slumped to his lowest ever nationwide favourability rating of -50, with just 21 per cent having a favourable view of the Labour leader, according to YouGov.

None of his other problems have gone away. The race for the deputy leadership of the Labour Party is going very wrong for him, with Lucy Powell in the lead. She is an ally of Andy Burnham, Mayor of Greater Manchester, who is starting to believe that he could replace Starmer. The PM still hasn’t managed to shake off questions regarding what he knew and when about Lord Mandelson’s relationship with Jeffrey Epstein.

Perhaps most devastating of all, the public finances confirm that Britain is racing ever more quickly towards national bankruptcy.

Rachel Reeves borrowed £83.8 bn in the first five months of this financial year alone. This is £16.2 bn above the same period last year and £11.4 bn above the Office for Budget Responsibility’s forecast. Worryingly, VAT and some other tax revenues were lower than expected in August.

Normally, at this stage of the economic cycle, we would expect the Government’s finances to be close to balanced; shockingly, the opposite is happening and they appear to be getting uncontrollably worse. The deficit is pump-priming the economy a la Keynes, ensuring that inflation stays too high and that the Bank of England can’t cut interest rates.

Lord Wolfson, Next’s brilliant chief executive, said that at best he expects anaemic growth, with four forces hurting the economy: “declining job opportunities, new regulation that erodes competitiveness, government spending commitments that are beyond its means, and a rising tax burden that undermines national productivity.” There are reports from Reed, the recruiting company, of a bloodbath in jobs for young people, caused in part by artificial intelligence.

The gulf between the US and UK economies keeps on widening, as I pointed out in my column this week. Real UK GDP per person has risen just 0.7 per cent since June 2019; by contrast, US real GDP per capita jumped by 9.2 per cent between 2019 and 2024, and has grown further since.

 
Graph showing UK growth continuing to struggle
 

We are barely getting richer per capita, and the Government, rather than admit to the public that we are living beyond our means, is borrowing more and more money to keep its deranged public spending binge going. It will end in tears sooner rather than later.

The so-called £150bn in investment deals announced as part of Trump’s state visit won’t make a blind bit of difference to this woeful picture. Yes, such spending is good news as far as it goes, but it will take years to materialise (meaning that the boost as a share of annual GDP will be quite small) and most major economies will end up in receipt of these sorts of expenditures.

Big tech firms need to spread their bases. Britain still has a strong knowledge base in AI, which helps us, but our tax, regulatory and energy policies appear designed to erode and undermine any advantage we may still retain.

 
Trump and Starmer
 

The investment deals announced during Trump’s state visit won’t make a blind bit of difference to the ultimate fate of the British economy

 

It’s all about to get worse: the growing black hole in Reeves’s public finances mean that another round of crippling tax rises is a certainty in the Budget. They will further dampen what is left of Britain’s animal spirits, and threaten a doom loop of higher tax, lower growth, even higher tax and so on.


Starmer’s desperate answer to his economic, fiscal, migratory and political crisis appears to be to rush through the recognition of a Palestinian state. We must all hope that one day Jews and Arabs will be able to coexist peacefully throughout the Middle East, but this isn’t the way to achieve it. We still live in the world that has existed for well over a hundred years: the Israelis want their own state, and the Palestinian elites don’t want them to have their own state. Their rejection of Israel is far more significant to them than obtaining a Palestinian state. Starmer is blind to this terrible reality.

His premature recognition will thus reward pogroms, rapes and murders carried out by Hamas, and has already proved to be an exceptionally costly act of virtue-signalling, derailing past attempts at releasing hostages.

From a cynical, purely domestic perspective, it won’t work either: the hard-Left and anti-Israel electorate will never be satisfied by anything Starmer can offer them. Corbyn’s new party may be in turmoil, but it, along with the Greens, the SNP and the Lib Dems, will continue to outflank Starmer on this question. Foreign policy posturing won’t solve Labour’s existential crisis.

Comments